Elizabeth Warren grills Bernanke during Senate Banking Committee testimony
February 27, 2013
Until Elizabeth Warren took the mic.
Sen. Warren, D-Mass., grilled Bernanke on "too big to fail" and the subsidy economists have calculated big banks get from the American taxpayers through preferential borrowing costs.
Here's what she said (via Bloomberg):
"Now
we have a double problem which is the big banks ... have gotten bigger
and at the same time ... investors believe with too big to fail out
there, that it's safer to put your money into the big banks and not the
big banks, effectively creating an insurance policy for the big banks
.... Last week Bloomberg did the math on it and came up with the number
$83 billion, that the big banks get in what is essentially a free
insurance policy ... So I understand that we're all trying to get to the
end of TBTF, but my question Mr. Chairman is, until we do, should those
biggest financial institutions be paying the American tax payer that
$83 billion subsidy they're getting."
Bernanke responded
that those subsidies are coming from the market's expectation that the
government will bail out banks, when in reality, the government has
figured out a way to wind them down. He also added that the government
wiped out the shareholders at AIG.To which Warren countered, "excuse me Mr. Chairman, but you did not wipe out the shareholders at the big banks ... Whatever you say, Mr. Chairman, $83 billion says there will be a bailout for financial institutions."
Eventually she pushed Bernanke until he said, "I think we should get rid of it."
The Bloomberg calculation Warren was talking about was in an editorial from last week. Here's the bit you need to see.
From Bloomberg:
Lately,
economists have tried to pin down exactly how much the subsidy lowers
big banks’ borrowing costs. In one relatively thorough effort, two
researchers — Kenichi Ueda of the International Monetary Fund and
Beatrice Weder di Mauro of the University of Mainz — put the number at
about 0.8 percentage point. The discount applies to all their
liabilities, including bonds and customer deposits.
Small
as it might sound, 0.8 percentage point makes a big difference.
Multiplied by the total liabilities of the 10 largest US banks by
assets, it amounts to a taxpayer subsidy of $83 billion a year. To put
the figure in perspective, it’s tantamount to the government giving the
banks about 3 cents of every tax dollar collected.
The
top five banks — JPMorgan, Bank of America Corp., Citigroup Inc., Wells
Fargo & Co. and Goldman Sachs Group Inc. — account for $64 billion
of the total subsidy, an amount roughly equal to their typical annual
profits ... In other words, the banks occupying the commanding heights
of the U.S. financial industry — with almost $9 trillion in assets, more
than half the size of the US economy — would just about break even in
the absence of corporate welfare ....
****************************************************************
#Elizabeth Warren.
No comments:
Post a Comment